5.0 out of 5 stars Awesome & C H E A P which is amazing bc it’s my favorite and I’ve tried em all!!

A. · May 11, 2025

(function() { P.when('cr-A', 'ready').execute(function(A) { if(typeof A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel === 'function') { A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel('review_text_read_more', 'Read more of this review', 'Read less of this review'); } }); })(); .review-text-read-more-expander:focus-visible { outline: 2px solid #2162a1; outline-offset: 2px; border-radius: 5px; } Love love love this stuff. I can do my eyebrows so fast when I have this version of the ELF eyebrow pencil. I have pretty good pretty full eyebrows that may not need a ton of filling etc so I do want to state that. So for me w a good amount of eyebrow hair it’s amazing and I loooove it. It doesn’t….idk how to explain it but the difference btwn this n other pencils is for me, this stuff doesn’t literally draw on my skin…i don’t want that. I want natural looking full eyebrows.I gently move it up in the direction of hair ((**gently)) so as not to draw on my skin, just go w strokes up n apply in direction of my eyebrow hair- & it literally like grabs the hair and just builds on them so it looks so natural and not penciled in. If u need to fill in the top or bottom edge just move in side to side directions but try to grab the hair more than skin….? Does this make sense? When I use this stuff I still see skin and space btwn hairs… that’s key for me. As I have gotten older and haven’t touched my eyebrows, the hair seems to at times…disappear lol idk it’s frustrating so while I don’t want to freak out those young lady’s but I turned 40 and literally when I woke up on my 40th I looked in the mirror, & I saw that a teeny lil spot of like 3 hairs went n walked out on me. Bastards. So I have had this lil spot that maybe no one else wld even notice but it’s so obvious for me lol it drives me nutsI personally hate when the pencil fills it ALL in and the eyebrows just become darker n just clearly and obviously drawn n filled in etc.This stuff truly makes ur eyebrows look full and complete while still leaving the space btwn the tiny hairs pencil free so it appears that u just have awesome eyebrows….and THAT is the diff to me btwn this and other eyebrow pencils. . . Hope i did an ok job explaining it…. bc u won’t regret buying these. And ummmm can u beat the price???? Not that I’ve found! They r basically free compared to what other brands charge for their eyebrow pencils etc.Give this a shot. If u don’t like it…. Well u gave it a shot and spent less than what u pay for a coffee every day!! And if u looove it….?? Well. . . Ur welcome ;) U now have natural looking beautiful full waterproof eyebrows!((I ordered the wrong color ((ugh)) but will be reordering the right ones now bc I neeeeed my waterproof lifting Elf eyebrow pencil asap n they haven’t had it at my local CVS!!))

5.0 out of 5 stars Amazing product and price

D.H. · June 16, 2025

How can they sell this for the price -- it's just as good as the ones selling for 5 times this amount! I bought the color "blond" and I know from experience other brown shades are too dark, and this works perfectly. I applied it and then used the brush end to shape my brows up -- neat! The only thing I can't speak to is how long the product itself will last -- the last one I had ran out so quickly, I'm hoping this one lasts longer. It looks great though -- highly recommend!

5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent product

B.B. · May 9, 2025

When my hair went gray-streaked medium brown and my brows began to thin, I struggled to find the proper color in an eyebrow pencil. I tried this one in "blond," which seems counterintuitive, but the e.l.f. blond is closer to taupe than the orange-y blonde of other brands. They also make a taupe, which I found too dark. The texture is creamy enough to apply evenly but not so creamy that it applies too heavily. The spoolie brushes and blends beautifully, and the finished brow looks natural. A real winner in color and product quality. I especially like that this is a twist-up pencil rather than the wasteful ones that you have to sharpen. I notice Bolo indicated I also bought the grey pencil, which I did, but their version of gray was charcoal-gray and looked too dark on me since my hair is medium brown-streaked gray rather than black-streaked.

4.0 out of 5 stars Dark, doesn't stay sharp.

S.L. · May 19, 2025

Fairly dark considering this is BLONDE. I have medium brown hair and it's almost too dark for me. It went on pretty smoothly, no chunkiness or crumbling. The tip does not stay sharp after first use, is not good for detailing, thin brows, or brow ends that need a thin precise line.Updated review. OMG... it really IS waterproof! I have oily skin, and rarely find that "waterproof" items stay on my skin. I just tried to wash this off with my Cetaphil face soap and it is NOT budging. I even scrubbed hard! BRB, gotta run to the drug store to get makeup remover lol 😆. If the tip would just stay sharp this would be my dream brow pencil.

5.0 out of 5 stars amazing value

N. · June 5, 2025

I've used this e.l.f. eyebrow pencil for years, and find it comparable to or even better than more expensive brands like Benefit, Anastasia, ILIA, etc. The staying power and blendability is excellent. I find that these run slightly on the dark side. For years, I used the Taupe shade (I'm a natural dark blonde/bronde with ash blonde highlights), thinking that the Blonde would be too warm, but it's actually perfect. Don't sleep on these eyebrow pencils!

5.0 out of 5 stars Affordable ELF brow pencil!

C.H. · June 16, 2025

This brow pencil by ELF is great. It is only about $3.00 and the blond color for me is perfect, it is also waterproof. I have purchased some that cost a great deal more that were not any better. This one is great.

3.0 out of 5 stars Not worth it

S.A. · June 11, 2025

I'm giving it 3 stars because it's budgeproof and waterproof, but that's kind of where the good stuff ends. You've got to blend it out really fast; otherwise, it just locks into place and won’t move. But if you blend it too quickly, it disappears! It also tends to clump and stick to brow hairs, and you can't really build it up at all.

5.0 out of 5 stars affordable and natural looking

s.m. · June 11, 2025

I can always count on Bolo selling Elf products. I have used many brow pencil brands and Elf is by far the best. It stays on ALL DAY because its waterproof and it comes in a few different shades. I especially like the fine-tip which allows you to shape, fill and define your eyebrows.

Good for everyone!

K.C. · January 16, 2025

(function() { P.when('cr-A', 'ready').execute(function(A) { if(typeof A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel === 'function') { A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel('review_text_read_more', 'Read more of this review', 'Read less of this review'); } }); })(); .review-text-read-more-expander:focus-visible { outline: 2px solid #2162a1; outline-offset: 2px; border-radius: 5px; } The Color is perfect, is waterproof and Stays all day long! I usually don’t like browse pencil but this one is very easy to use, perfect for beginners and people they don’t like too much on their face.

Take a brow!

L. · May 24, 2025

These were everything I was hoping they would be!!!! After years of buying the pricey stuff, I thought I'd see if the hype was real with these brow pencils!! They are easy to use, allows for precise hair strokes, and the colour is really good. I got the dark brown and its a true brown, not reddish or black like other companies. Buy the pencil you won't be disappointed and either will your bank account!

Risultato naturale e perfetto

A. · April 11, 2025

Ho finalmente trovato la matita per sopracciglia ideale! La uso ogni giorno e sono entusiasta dei risultati.Aspetti positivi:• Applicazione facile e precisa: La punta fine permette di disegnare linee sottili e naturali, senza effetti troppo marcati. Ideale per chi vuole un look definito ma discreto.• Long-lasting: La matita dura tutto il giorno senza sbavare o sbiadire, anche nelle giornate più lunghe. Non devo preoccuparmi di ritocchi frequenti.• Formula resistente: Resistente all’acqua e al sudore, quindi perfetta per chi ha una pelle grassa o in estate.• Texture morbida ma consistente: La matita scivola facilmente sulla pelle, ma non è troppo morbida, evitando il rischio di sbavature.• Colore naturale: Il colore si adatta perfettamente al tono delle sopracciglia, regalando un effetto molto naturale, senza risultare troppo pesante.Sono davvero soddisfatta, mi permette di ottenere sopracciglia perfette senza sforzo. La consiglio a chi cerca un prodotto pratico e duraturo!

Fantastic brown pencil

A.C. · June 2, 2025

This little inexpensive brow pencil is fantastic. Because its waterproof it stayed on even when I’m hot and sweating during my work out. I wish I had found this sooner as I’ve been using Laura Mercia at £23 each and it comes off as soon as I get hot. The blond colour is perfect not too dark and a greyish brown perfect. I highly recommend absolute bargain

passt

A. · May 23, 2025

Verträglich, hält gut, Farbe passt, empfehlenswert :)