5.0 out of 5 stars I'm a believer

K.V. · April 23, 2019

I've been following @theflexibledietinglifestyle on Instagram for a few months now and I've seen him promote this stuff like crazy, always wondering if it was too good to be true. I've recently been paying more attention to my nutrition and tracking my macros, but I have a HUGE sweet tooth, which sometimes makes it tricky to stay within my goals. I finally caved once I realized he was selling on Bolo, and I'm so glad I did. This stuff is AMAZING. I love Oreos, and when I opened the package that's the exact smell I got. I added two tablespoons to my light and fit vanilla greek yogurt and was obsessed, it tastes like a THICC oreo frosty and was unbelievably good for the macros! My whole family is a fan now and I'm going to end up hiding this container from them (selfish - sorry!). I love how it has the recipes linked to give you a ton of ideas for how you can utilize this stuff, which makes me even more curious about his cookbook. This guy is truly onto something and I'm so glad the few mixed reviews didn't stop me from trying this stuff, now I want the other flavor too! The only flaw was how it arrived in an envelope rather than a box like I had expected, but still, 11/10 recommend, you NEED this product.

5.0 out of 5 stars GREAT PRODUCT! MACRO FRIENDLY! GREAT TASTE

A.F. · May 18, 2019

This product is great both in macros and taste! It’s quick, convenient, and has limitless uses! I use this spread a lot on my rice cakes & oatmeal it blends perfectly and adds a great taste no weird textures but maybe a slight bitter aftertaste. Just add stevia or any other sweetener replacement and it will eliminate that issue completely.Will definitely continue using this product as well as the Vanilla Cookie flavor(My personal favorite)

4.0 out of 5 stars Terrible taste but the seller IS AMAZING

F. · August 13, 2023

This is an update to my prior reviewing"I'm not sure who would use this as a spread on its own. It has an absolutely awful, synthetic taste. I also bought the brownie batter I'm praying is edible but I don't have high hopes If I could return it I would, I'm just going to try mixing it with other things to avoid waste."Addendum- the seller reached out to me of their own accord apologize for my experience and worked with me to find a solution. I'm not sure if I just got a bad batch or what but the company went out if their way to make it right. Bumped up the rating because the company deserved it!

1.0 out of 5 stars Read this before you buy, so you don’t make the mistake that I did.

C. · July 21, 2025

I just wanted to come on here and write a review because I don’t want anybody to make the same mistake that I did. I have been purchasing flavored peanut butter powder to stay on my macros and I thought this would be a great substitute because the company I’ve been buying from is no longer in business. This had great reviews so I purchased it, and I thought the fact that it had protein and it was an amazing plus. I was super excited to try it, but honestly, it was one of the grossest things that I’ve eaten in a really long time. I literally could not finish my rice cakes with this “butter” on top. I mixed it with water like I normally do with similar products. I had to throw it out and do my workout on an empty stomach. I can still taste it if I think about it too hard. 🤮🤢It was seriously nasty. I know that somebody spent a lot of time developing this product and I’m so sorry to leave a negative review, but I don’t understand how this has so many positive reviews when it tastes seriously bad. I also want to add that I am very used to eating protein powder and very used to eating no sugar products, but this just really misses the mark.

3.0 out of 5 stars Good taste but…..

e. · March 3, 2024

i don’t usually write reviews but im gonna do it this time. After reading some other reviews i decided to give a try even thought people says it taste like chemical or it gives a bad taste to your mouth after eating eat. For me at least for me i liked the flavor ( i only mixed with water and a few grams of powder) and to be honest it taste good. The only complain i would like to add is YES I RECEIVED WITH THE JAR OPEN. The paper lit which is suppose to be a seal for a product was half opened and my product arrived kinda covered with powder around the jar and the cover cup ( thats something that most of people who buys this product complains about). Im not sure if it arrived like that because thats the way how they fill up the container with the powder or theres something fishy here) so yeah if you gonna buy this product expect to receive it open. not sure how much amount of product you might receive for the price.Am I gonna buy it again? Well….. i think might be my second option powder.

5.0 out of 5 stars Cookie butter protein is the shizzzzz

k. · February 7, 2020

Soooo this is my favorite protein filled treat every flavor is amazing! This one I use in Greek yogurt to add some pizzazz and I’m oats and milk sea salt chocolate oat bowls of heaven it’s like it was sent to me straight from the gods. So freaking amazing. Cookie butter I use in cookie dough oats, as a coffee creamer or in homemade edible cookie dough or just slather that bad boy all up on a delicious banana. The fruity cereal one I make oat bowls wirh then sprinkle a little of the real deal on top I don’t even miss eating a whole box of fruity pebbles because this fills that void. Last but not least is the cinnamon roll flavor I make oat bowls of joy mostly with that and slap an egg on top for some sweet and savory goodness. I suggest you buy as many of every flavor as you can because you won’t regret it and you’ll become a cookie protein butter addict like myself. Nobody’s paying me to write this awesome review I just really freaking like this product.

2.0 out of 5 stars Better Manufacturing needed

E.H. · February 21, 2025

I just got my order today, I haven't had a chance to try it because it came with the top partially off, the safety seal lifted, and half of the powder in the bottom of the delivery bag. I read so many reviews on how people were receiving orders messed and I hoped it was a fluke that was fixed, clearly not. I'm not sure if I would purchase again as I haven't had a chance to taste it, but I will say that losing so much of the product and having safety seals that don't work is definitely starting off my idea of the brand as negative. This is my first time buying. I'll write another review after I actually use it for about a week.