5.0 out of 5 stars nice flavor, good texture, would get it again.

S. · May 15, 2025

(function() { P.when('cr-A', 'ready').execute(function(A) { if(typeof A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel === 'function') { A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel('review_text_read_more', 'Read more of this review', 'Read less of this review'); } }); })(); .review-text-read-more-expander:focus-visible { outline: 2px solid #2162a1; outline-offset: 2px; border-radius: 5px; } I liked the flavor, texture, consistency of the product. didn't love the fact that it is kind of pricey but, well I guess I have paid more money for stuff that isn't even good.this is a good spread, you can eat it directly with a spoon, on a cracker, on bread. I liked the chunks of pretzels, stirred it up to combine the chocolate and pretzels into the Peanut Butter and it was really good.

5.0 out of 5 stars Amazing

P.d. · June 11, 2025

This is so good I could cry. I’m pregnant. Thank you

1.0 out of 5 stars I stupidly decided to buy two jars- Birthday Cake and Choc Chip Cookie Dough

A.W. · October 24, 2024

I never write reviews. Mostly because I feel bad and don't want to hurt the business with a negative review.However, this is an exception. This product is absolutely DISGUSTING. It arrived oil spilling from jars, allover the Bolo package. Very messy to clean from the start without even having opening the jar.Still I was optimistic.....I had seen so many AWESOME reviews that surely it had to be lovely.I opened the jars and what stared me back was 1.5 inches of THICK oil. Okay No problem... ill stir and mix it in. IT DOES NOT mix easily. I mean I struggled, "the protein spread" AKA cement was like caked like cement to the bottom of the jar. Trying to mix it was nearly impossible after abut 20 soemthing minutes, oil now spilling over sides of jars and counter I was frustrated. It was as mixed as it would ever get.So now, still optimistic lets taste it.I bought two jars:1-Choc Chip Cookie Dough2- Birthday cakeThey taste nothing like what was advertised. The flavor profiles did not taste like birthday cake or cookie dough. It tasted like a strange artificial thick, pasty spread. Its chalky, leaves a very strong after taste that leaves little to be desired.I thought it was just me.... My younger sister came to visit me with some of her college aged girl friends. They saw the jars and asked me about it. I feel guilty to admit this.. but I happily and enthusiastically encouraged them to try a BIG spoonful each. Needless to say they were Not pleased with what they tasted. Two of the girls spit it out in my kitchen sink. At least one girl was discreet and spit it into a paper towel. Needless to say the visit didn't get off on a great foot.

4.0 out of 5 stars Seriously good stuff!

R.S. · March 18, 2025

Depending on flavor, this might be the best PB that ever crossed my lips! Seriously good. It's a little drippy, which is good to stir up the oil and the chips, etc...this stuff might not last the week. It's that good!Here's my thoughts on the flavors I've tried so far:1) Salted caramel. Pretty good! No chips or whatnot in this one, but tasty.2) Chocolate chip- Now my fav! My chips melted and were at the bottom, so I gave it a good stir and oh wow.3) White chocolate and Pretzel: 2nd runner up and really good. YUM!4) I finally ordered the PB cup one, tastes good- but I live in Florida, and it arrived totally melted. So, the little cups were completely gone. I'm sure I would have loved them...5) My 2nd least favorite is Cookie Butter. It's just okay, sort of an odd taste to it.6) and finally, my least favorite is Birthday cake. There's an almond extract type of flavor, I'm guessing to emulate "cake", but I hate almond extract. Literally hate it...and even if it's not in there, it tastes like it is. I ended up throwing this one away.If you are on the fence, try the chocolate chip one first and go from there!

5.0 out of 5 stars Yum Yum Yum

G.T. · June 10, 2025

Very tasty. Would purchase again.

3.0 out of 5 stars 🎂🍰 doesn't rly taste like BDAY CAKE | Too Sugary, Gritty, Chalky, Hard-to-Spread; major separation = MUST MIX everytime! 🍰🎂

A.C. · October 9, 2017

🥜 🥜 🥜 Tun-da-da-dun...🎂🍰 doesn't rly taste like BDAY CAKE | Too Sugary, Gritty, Chalky, Hard-to-Spread; major separation = MUST MIX everytime! 🍰🎂🎂 This review is for the BIRTHDAY CAKE version.~ NOTE: I'll update with pix, when I can afford to take the time to do so!🎂 [INTRO]This is my very FIRST time ever buying something like this!I've never really bought anything "High Protein" or a "High Protein Peanut Butter" or a Specialty "Flavored Peanut Butter".I weally Weally wanted to like (scratch that...lurv) this peanut butter.I read the product detail page for this...I read all the questions, reviews, etc.I even watched this video online, regarding the founders of the company & how their ma was vital to their success/launch.Their sorta odd & off sense of humor was awkward but sorta likable lol.🎂 [TASTE]I don't get to eat "BIRTHDAY CAKE" on a regular basis...Hah, I kinda wish someone would pay me though 😛but this does not really taste like cake.It kinda tastes more like an extra sweetened, vanilla-infused, cake batter in the form of a nut spread.🎂 [CONSISTENCY]- Gritty- kinda Chalky, not as smooth.Idk maybe this is how a "high protein peanut butter" is supposed to taste like?!...maybe this is how all protein products are?!...hopefully not.I wna continue this journey to a healthier path, starting with what I put in my mouth/body.But hey lemme indulge a bit, while I'm at it... 🍰 *** My birthday IS coming up very soon! *** 🍰🎂 [SPREADABILITY]Since this is kind of hard & one lump of a mass, I suggest possibly heating this up in the microwave or something.You could also put this on toast (fresh out the toaster) or some other hot bread or something warm/hot.I don't know if the plastic jar is microwaveable & also if the jar is BPA-free, so prolly transfer it to another container 1st.❄ This container says, "WE SUGGEST STORING IN A COOL, DRY PLACE OR REFRIGERATE TO PRESERVE FRESHNESS. 55F - 68F" ❄I've never had to store a peanut butter in a refrigerator before. I've a small ref.🎂 [AROMA]- I like the smell though. It smells lovely, almost like a bakery.- I wish it tasted as good as it smelled. It contains like a pseudo-intoxicating aroma that seems more sinful than it is.🎂 [APPEARANCE]The actual color of this peanut butter is like a light brown with colorful sprinkles mixed in.The sprinkles are crunchy yo.🎂 [sir MIX-A-LOT]Ohh-mah-gawd...you have GOT TO MIX this peanut butter like crazy!I've never ever had to mix any peanut butter before...ever!Even before I opened the lid & seal on top, I could tell there was this "separation" going on.I opened it & behold...I was majestically correct!___The liquid that separated was like a semi-transparent and light colored watery/runny consistency.I've bought peanut butters before & didn't really care if the oil or whatever separated...I could deal.{Just gimme my protein dosage already...argh my high metabolism is makin' me hangry & want a lil bit muscle!)...but...this particular peanut butter was literally a SOLID thick chunky hard mass VERSUS a runny LIQUID.Jeezuz y'all haven't been on a date with my lips yet...and already y'all on a "break" 🙄I want me some bday pb darnet...not a rock & runny liquid!___I'm no body-builder or anythin like that...so it was quite HARD to try to mix the entire jar.I don't have a stand up mixer or even a hand mixer, so I had to deal with mixing this peanut butter using a spoon.🥄 This container says, "OIL SEPARATION MAY OCCUR, STIR WITH EVERY USE."🎂 [REASON FOR BUYING]I wanted to use this as a topping to spread on pancakes/future biscuits.I also planned on mixing this with oatmeal to make it creamier, healthier, yummier & more filling.(Oatmeal doesn't fill me up, even though it claims to. I've a high metabolism so am always hungry & also why I'm pretty skinny).Basically, I wanted my breakfast foods/breakfast meals to be yummier but still healthier and filling at the same time.I also want to try to consume more protein (albeit, more cost-effectively) to build some muscle, possibly tone up & be more full (vs hungry right after).🎂 [SUGGESTIONS]- 100% Certified Organic version?- Less Sugars- Remove "Sugar Alcohol" (3 grams) & use a natural sweetener instead (ie: stevia, raw honey, etc)- Lactose-Free (to make it easier on the gut, for people who are lactose-intolerant...but painfully stubborn)- Sell a 2-pack or a 3-pack, some bulk version like what those big warehouses do so you can offer it cheaper (y'know what they say it's cheaper to buy in bulk)- Or possibly sell a larger size bottle (ie: 30 oz)- Bundle/Flavor Pack where the consumer can sample like 1 oz of each flavor without the commitment in case they don't like the taste/can't afford to buy all the flavors.- Referral program where you can earn jars for people who purchase using your code- Affiliate program for food bloggers, health bloggers or something like that..- Loyalty/Rewards Program: Buy 3, Get 4th jar free (or something similar). A way to "earn" free jars would be cool.- Maybe you could reduce the price by selling a "refill" type of pouch like those laundry detergents that come with a pouch to refill (& the included lid).People could just wash their plastic jars & refill with the same product (just at a reduced cost). If they wanted to get all the product out, they could just cut the foil or package & lick/spoon the rest of the nut butter out.🎂 [CONCLUSION]- If I can find this brand cheaper somewhere else I think I'd buy more often. It's just not really cost-effective for the current budget, unfortunately.- Til the transition from starving artist/fully paying off student loans is complete...it's kinda mission impossible to consume this celebratory flavored gooey dessert-like treat.- But at the same time nobody wants that dreaded Freshman 15 lmAo.- It's hard to justify munching/snacking on this everyday...so I'd have to label this a luxury item for the time being.____________________________________________🎈 Taste = 3 / 5 stars (refine the gritty/chalky texture)🎈 Quality = 2.5 / 5 (too sugary for a "healthy" alternative peanut butter)🎈 Value = 2 / 5 (a bit overpriced)🎈 Overall = 2.5 / 5 (average, read more below)This jar says, "100% PRODUCT SATISFACTION" but unfortunately I'm not 100% satisfied with this product...especially not at the high price I paid for it.This is like some designer peanut butter. I've designer products & designer items but never purchased designer nut butter. I had higher standards & much higher expectations. I wanted to fly man. 🐱🏍___🎈 Would I recommend to a friend?Mixed Yes & No (if you can get past the grit & chalk texture)🎈 Would I buy again? Possibly Yes (but saved for special occasions or if they have a sale)🙂 If you're awesome & found this review helpful, then click "Yes"! 🙂

5.0 out of 5 stars YUMMY!

L. · May 3, 2025

I had to try it as soon as I got it. Couldn’t wait. OMG this is incredible! I love it! It’s so yummy and I can’t believe I didn’t discover this before. Now I have and I’m hooked. I’ll try some of the other flavors now. Would highly recommend.

5.0 out of 5 stars Umum

P. · May 29, 2025

Very good product with pretzels in it.

Delicious

S. · March 15, 2025

(function() { P.when('cr-A', 'ready').execute(function(A) { if(typeof A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel === 'function') { A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel('review_text_read_more', 'Read more of this review', 'Read less of this review'); } }); })(); .review-text-read-more-expander:focus-visible { outline: 2px solid #2162a1; outline-offset: 2px; border-radius: 5px; } Delicious but expensive and container was only half full

Richtig geil!!! Suchtgefahr!!!

m. · April 15, 2016

Der Geschmack ist bombastisch und der Konsistenz super zum streichen/verzieren von Pancakes oder ähnliches. Kann ich wirklich allen Erdnussbutter-Fans empfehlen :)

Lecker, aber...

A.K. · June 8, 2017

Leider zum zweiten Mal ein anscheinend sehr altes Produkt erhalten.Ich habe diese Erdnussbutter bereits drei Mal bestellt, weil sie wirklich hervorragend schmeckt. Bei zwei von drei mal hab ich jedoch ein Glas erhalten, bei dem die gesamte eigentliche Erdnussbutter eingetrocknet war und das Öl der Erdnussbutter oben schwamm. Kriegt man nur mit viel Mühe und Geduld wieder cremig!

Amazing 🤩 a bit pricey but worth it for nutrition value but not spreadable!

E.J. · March 29, 2024

This product is for eating with a spoon not for spreading!!! It's VERY DENSE! Not for lunches etc.. I don't seem to have any of the problems with food products and that's probably because I live in Toronto and am close to a Bolo wear house so this product arrived in perfect condition unlike some other reviews say. Perfect 👍. It tastes amazing and although on the pricer side of things especially for a lower carb, high protein product like this!

Great Taste, feels like a cookie butter texture with the richness of butter cream.

K. · February 11, 2023

Great birthday cake taste reminds me of cupcake butter cream, the texture reminds me of a cookie butter (speculoos)Good amount of protein compared to cookie butter, slightly more protein than actual peanut butter.They use Protein insolate which is good, and the ingredients are pretty natural.would reccomend on sale or stick to protein bars/powders for your protein needs.