5.0 out of 5 stars Redford and Baseball: Works for Me!

O. · July 31, 2020

The version I purchased of The Natural was the two-disk Director's Cut set. I liked that viewers had the option at the very beginning to listen to Barry Levinson, the director, explain in brief how the cut altered the movie from the original theatrical release. Now, I saw the movie in the theater and once or twice on cable over the years, but honestly, I don't remember the original that specifically to tell what the differences are. I do appreciate having Levinson's comment about the changes up front, though. Viewers don't have to listen that first, but it's presented above the 'play movie' for those who are interested in doing so as I was.I enjoy Robert Redford movies and before the era of steroids and ridiculous salaries, I loved baseball, so seeing this in the theater upon release was natural for me. I recall liking it and thinking it was a bit slow in places, so buying the Director's Cut to see if that slowness was taken away, was also a natural for me. I may not enjoy baseball like I once did, but I still like a good Redford film performance.Levinson removed several minutes from the movie's first cut, rearranged and edited, and ultimately added five minutes and in total, this lengthened the movie by five minutes. The opening was definitely more tight, as he called it. Years ago, I remember thinking the opening in particular was so slow, almost dark and dreary, and I did not feel that way in watching the DVD today.Redford is Roy Hobbs, initially a young man with a bright future in baseball until he gets shot by a mysterious woman. It's sixteen years later when he finally gets a shot at the big leagues, although not everyone is on his side, including the manager (Wilford Brimley) who refuses to play such an old rookie. He doesn't even let him practice, until one day when Hobbs challenges him. Then the manager gets a big shock: this old rookie can play.From there, it's baseball drama and folks wanting to solve the mystery of Roy Hobbs' past while also putting in play a bit of a Black Sox scandal. The supporting cast is full of top notch actors, such as Glenn Close and Robert DuVall. Darrin McGavin, Kim Bassinger, Barbara Hershey, and Robert Prosky were also part of the cast. The big finale is an explosive delight, the kind that makes a fan cheer and smile with excitement. It takes a while to get there, but it's a good journey.The second disk has all of the bonus material, including a feature (in parts without a 'play all' option which annoys me) on the creation of the story and getting the movie made. It was truly interesting to hear the director and Redford discuss the ending of the movie and how it was changed from the novel, which provides a darker, more sad ending than what is seen in the film. That's followed by short "extras" that discuss different aspects of the movie, such as making era-appropriate uniforms, use of slow motion, and the one question President Reagan had about the movie.Next comes a segment called Clubhouse Conversations which includes folks like George Will, Bob Costas, Ryne Sandberg, Jason Giambi, and Don Mattingly talking (individually, not together) about the game of baseball. After this comes the shocking story of a baseball player shot by a female stalker. Though severely injured, he survived and returned to the game of baseball. She was the inspiration for the Barbara Hershey character in The Natural. The last part of this extra is about the various mythologies used in the novel and in the movie."The Heart of The Natural" is a featurette that features Cal Ripken Jr. on the gift or talent to play the game. This extends to include topics like the media and the business of the game. He also talks about heroes and the concept of role models.So, strong Redford performance, good drama, satisfying ending, and interesting extras make this an excellent DVD. Truly, my only complaint is the lack of a 'play all' option for that initial extra on The Natural coming together. Commentary would have been great, too, but as it is, the Director's Cut set is well worth it.

5.0 out of 5 stars One of the most perfect baseball movies ever!

w. · October 6, 2025

One of the most perfect baseball movies ever! RIP Robert Redford

5.0 out of 5 stars Movie

K. · September 27, 2025

Good movie

5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant baseball epic

M.G. · September 20, 2025

The greatest baseball movie ever

5.0 out of 5 stars Engaging plot, great performances by principal actors, excellent AV transfer

J.E.L. · May 22, 2025

Sound and video were excellent--in the 4K disc rendition we watched. Great drama not often found in recent movies. Redford, Sam Neill, Kristin Scott Thomas, and even Scarlett Johannson delivered.

4.0 out of 5 stars My favorite sports movie

R.H. · November 4, 2003

I'm really torn with the Director's Cut. On one hand, I was glad to get the never-before-seen scenes. On the other, I thought this film was fine the way it was. The Director's Cut came off as being much "darker" than the original.I guess my one big complaint about the Director's Cut is that even though they added a lot more scenes, they also took a few away. I didn't mind the flashbacks, but they took away some of the dialogue between the Whammer and Hobbs on the train. There were a couple other fairly inconsequential scenes that are no longer in the film.The original was easier to follow, and I wonder how easy it would be to follow the Director's Cut without having seen the original. Since Robert Redford played Hobbs when he first set out to start his career, it might be a little confusing for those who see those early scenes, while at the same time seeing a "grown up" Hobbs as he reflects on his life. The only thing that might help clear it up is when Hobbs mentions that he was out of the game for 16 years.Also, I gave the original film the benefit of the doubt with regards to the games that were played at Wrigley Field. When Hobbs hits the home run that breaks the clock, it appears as though it was a game ending home run, due to the editing, but if you look closely, none of the players walk off the field as though the game is over (the Cubs would have last at bats.) However, when he hits four home runs the next day, you can clearly hear the announcer's voiceovers describe the home runs as being hit in the bottom of each inning. Oops.I don't want to spoil anything, but there was one interesting new scene between Bump and Roy. Given that Bump was just told that he has one more chance to shape up, his actions towards Roy aren't surprising at all.Despite his MAJOR flaws with regards to the shady women in his life, Roy Hobbs is still a hero. I would still highly recommend either one of these films, but would probably favor the original. I could have enjoyed a Director's Cut even if they just put the new scenes into their special features disc instead of ingrained into the actual movie.Whammer, "Scared?"Hobbs, "Not of you, I'm not."

5.0 out of 5 stars The Natural ... when good movies were the norm rather than the exception

p. · February 23, 2020

I originally watched this movie around the time it was released (1984) and I liked it back then. So I felt like watching it again (2020). I was literally blown away this time by how good a movie it was compared to what typically passes for a film lately. Character development done right, plot development done right, montages done effectively, many subtle scenes with excellent acting all around mark this as a great classic. Robert Redford, Robert Duvall, Glenn Close, Kim Basinger, Wilford Brimley - who could ask for more talented actors. I can only point to perhaps one small plot weakness which I won't be specific about here to avoid spoiling, but otherwise this is the great classic hero story.There is a certain demographic that, thanks to today's identity politics, may have more difficulty finding good stories like this to which they can relate. This film may be particularly inspirational to people who might feel like their lives didn't turn out the way they had hoped and have trouble seeing the silver lining. I wouldn't be surprised if this film is eventually rebooted at some point with countless revisions to make it conform to the political ideology rampant in today's Hollywood, but this is one of the main reasons that I find myself going back to watch these films that I love one more time before they get ruined or become difficult to find in their original form.

Reçu en bon état.

F.P. · December 18, 2022

Bon film assez ancien, mais l'histoire est bien.Le rêve de chacun peut être réalisé avec le temps.

Good Movie

J.P. · March 16, 2025

A classic

Der Unbeugsame BD (Robert Redford)

C. · December 10, 2011

Film: 5 SterneBild: 5 SterneTon: 5 SterneCover: FSK-freies WendecoverFilm: Dieser Klassiker liegt hier im DC vor, die entsprechenden erweiternden Scenen wurden unsynchronisiert im Original belassen, leider fielen dabei auch einige Sätze der bereits synchronisierten Version zum Opfer. Der Film ist eine Hommage an's Baseball, ein ruhiger Film mit toller Musik. Ein Vergleich zu einem alten Film mit Kathrine Hepurn und Spencer Tracey fällt mir hierbei auf, in dem Hepurn eine Tennisspielerin mimt, die in Anwesenheit von Tracey immer nicht zu ihrem Spiel findet und verliert. Das gleiche dumme Prinzip hat man hier gewählt. In dem Moment wo Redford mit Memo (Bassinger) zusammen ist trifft er keinen Ball mehr; Drehbuchautoren können manchmal so uninspiriert sein. Nichtsdestotrotz liebe ich diesen Film.Bild: Im 1:1.85 Format, schön, endlich wieder Vollbild. Wenn ich keinen Film mit Landschaftspanoramaaufnahmen habe, ziehe ich diese Format hier vor. Bildqualität ist tadellos. Schärfe, Kontrast, Schwarzwert und Sättigung sind anstandtslos. Mein TV ist ein 1,50 mtr Plasma, und Aufnahmen wie z.B. das Duell zwischen Redford und "Dem Hammer" auf dem Jahrmarkt sind der absolute Highlight. Die Bilder die hier entstanden sind zählen für mich zu den schönsten Aufnahmen im Filmbereich. Während dem Werfer- Schlägerspiel arbeitet die Kamera perfekt mit Tiefenschärfespielen und fängt auch wunderbar die vielen kleinen Partikel wie Blüten oder Insekten ein, welche um die Protagonisten herum träge unscharf ihre Kreise ziehn, während die Kamera auf die Spieler focusiert bleibt. Auch während des restlichen Films gibt es immer wieder solche schönen Momente. Der Kameramann hat hier bei dem Spiel mit der Tiefenschärfe alle Register gezogen, das Ergebnis ist hervorragend.Ton: DTS-HD, man braucht nur die 1. Minute im Film zu sehn, und ist voll zufrieden. Bei einem Sportfilm erwartet man einen brauchbaren Ton und erwartet keine so große Umsetzung im Bassbereich. Wenn jedoch in der 1. Minute ein Zug von links nach recht gemächlich durch's Bild rollt, mit bimmelnder Glocke und dampfgetrieben, gibt mein Subwoofer mir das deutlichst zu verstehn. Im Zug sitzt Redford danach auf der rechten Seite und meine linke hinter Box spielt mir Umgebunggeräusche ein, schön umgesetzt. Auch beim Rest des Film setzt sich diese liebevolle Umgestaltung des Tons fort, und wenn Redford dann mal den Ball in das Flutlicht schlägt reißt mein Subwoofer mich wieder mal aus der Stille raus, toll. Ton ist anstandslos.Menü: Sony, sonst würde ich es nicht erwähnen. Ich liebe Sony Menüs, schlicht und praktisch, geziert von im Hintergrund ablaufenden Filmszenen in bester Qualität.Auch hier wieder nur 3 Sprachen, alle mit der gleichen Tonart - DTS-HD (Englisch, Japanisch, Deutsch).Fazit: Perfekter kann man einen Film nicht auf BD transferieren, klare Kaufempfehlung.P.S. Universum und Warner, bitte schaut bei Sony wie man Menüs gestaltet, dann braucht der ehrliche Käufer einer BD-Scheibe nicht 5 Minuten zu warten bevor der Film losgeht.

見る度に楽しい気持ちになる

A.カ. · September 5, 2025

VHSを持っていたのですが、画像が粗く見るに堪えなくなったので、購入しました。見る度に爽やかな気分になれる傑作だと思います。

problème décrochage VF sur l'import

n. · January 30, 2013

Testé sur PS3The natural (sorti dans les salles sous le titre français "le meilleur" en 1984)est un très beau film certes de facture classique, mais passionnant sur un joueur de base ball (Redford) revenu de loin et devenu à force d'opiniâtreté et de talent "le meilleur". Le film a été réalisé par Barry Levinson, avec une pléiade de stars (Robert Redford, Glenn Close, Kim Basinger, Robert Duval entre autres), magnifique à la photo et à la reconstitution d'une époque, le film est un classique américain.Sortie en blu ray import US, et inédit en France dans ce format le film est en région FREE!!!Mais..... c'est là que les ennuis commencent...si le film bénéficie d'une piste audio française avec sous titres français, les bonus (passionnants)ne sont proposés qu'en anglais avec sous titrages espagnol et portugais uniquement. Autre problème plus embêtant un décrochage constaté sur la VF ou le film repasse en VO durant une scène de restaurant pendant au moins deux minutes....Donc pour résumé :Profiter de ce magnifique film en import blu ray est possible sur les platine française mais préférer la V.O sous titré français pour un meilleur confort, et maitriser l'anglais (ou l'espagnol ou encore le portugais) pour profiter pleinement des bonus.note film 4/5. Blu ray 2/5 (à cause des problèmes cités ci dessus)