5.0 out of 5 stars World-class photographs, but a presentation that doesn't quite match.

D. · December 1, 2011

The photographs in this book are immensely beautiful; uncannily unique, well-composed, subtle, thoughtful, and genuinely interesting to look at. These are pictures which I have little doubt will change how we think about, look at, and take photographs. Maier's work will become the standard which all other similar bodies of work will be judged by.It is odd and most unfortunate that no attempt was made to get in contact with Maier during her lifetime. Her work was discovered in 2007, and it wasn't until 2009 that she died. This left two full years to allow for even an acknowledgement to her that her work had been found. From what I've read, there is nothing indicating she had any aliments that would have inhibited her from communicating with anyone, even late in her life.The consequence of this lack of communication can be certainly found in this book. While the arrangement of the pictures is decent, it lacks the flow and subtlety that is present with the photographer arranging his own work - or even an artist close to him, who knows something about what the artist thought about the work. While it is known that Maier made narrative films and audio documentaries, it doesn't seem like she explicitly shared any insight about her photographs. This allows for sometimes questionable interpretations about her and her work which is distressing. For example, in the introduction by Maloof, he writes. "...the combination of Maier's intense privacy and lack of confidence in her own photographic prowess nearly resulted in her collection being consigned to oblivion." How in the world does he know that Maier lacked confidence in her work? "Street" photography - and I don't even really like calling it that - is something that requires a huge amount of confidence, both in your pictures and in your integrity as a photographer. There were likely very personal and fitful reasons why she never revealed her work which we will never be able to fathom, and it is meanwhile completely unfair to make statements or even educated assumptions about something we know absolutely nothing about.On the point of arrangement of the photographs: pictures with similar shapes and patterns are put together on a page. This does bring attention to the excellent composition of the images, but this detracts focus from some of the more subtle details in an individual picture. It also makes the work seem repetitive, which both her work and street photography in general is certainly not. Many photographs that dominate two pages feel lonely and distant, and would mend well together with certain other pictures in the book. On the other hand, some pictures which share pages with other images are so quirky that they deserve two pages alone. There is a section at the end of the book full of self-portraits which is well-executed.Printing quality is good with sufficient detail - though a bit dark, and I don't think the warm tone that was chosen compliments the work. Paper stock is glossy and of a good quality, and the construction of the book is solid. The cover is a neutral light gray cloth with the title, author, and publisher stamped on the spine and the initials "VM" stamped on the front cover. End-paper is a quirky orange. Printed in China, as are most photo books these days.I wish that sometime in the future Maloof will hand this wonderful collection over to a trust or company that really knows how to publish photographs, such as the MOMA, so the work gets the presentation that it deserves. I'm exceptionally glad that he was able to unify this collection (after a lot if it got sold off) - and it's obvious that he genuinely cares about this work, but these pictures should be handled by a company or trust which is more accustomed with dealing with this high level of work.The value of this book is great, but do keep in mind that it doesn't hold the level of quality that a "fine art" book would have, published a company such as Twin Palms or Steidl. It is a true pity that Maier could never share thoughts about her work. However, if you hold the mindset of letting the photographs truly speak for themselves, you'll be very pleased with this book.

5.0 out of 5 stars Beautiful Photos

J. · July 27, 2025

Beautiful selection of her photos. I hope there’s more. I’m not a photographer, but I like her angles and what she finds interesting.

5.0 out of 5 stars A powerful set of images

P.G. · May 4, 2025

She was an amazing unknown photographer. After watching a documentary on her life, I had to get this book to add to my library. If you are a street photographer and love the old school Black and White images, you will learn by just sitting and absorbing these amazing images. 5-stars. The book is very well printed.

5.0 out of 5 stars I love ❤️ this book

C.B. · July 26, 2025

Lovely book!! Nice pictures

4.0 out of 5 stars Must have for street photographers

S.P. · January 21, 2025

If you cut through some people's criticism based on how her work was found and monetized, you'll see she deserves to be recognised for her talent. The only thing I don't understand is why the images are so sepia, brown tinged. I have prints of some of the images with much better tonality. It would be nice to see an update second edition at some point.

5.0 out of 5 stars Maravilloso

E. · October 4, 2025

Es un libro bien editado, las imágenes digitalizadas muy nítidas, Vivían Mairs una gran fotógrafa de calle, por lo que vale la pena está adquisición para enriquecerse tu cultura visual

5.0 out of 5 stars The World Hiding in Plain Sight

L.B. · September 20, 2014

Maier is not the first artist whose work was only discovered after their death, but she is the most recent major one. And a major artist she is - these photographs testify to a talent on par with any of the other photographic luminaries of the 20th century. It only adds to the mystique that she took these images as a hobby, wandering the streets of New York and Chicago with the children she was babysitting in tow. As the book points out, not only was no one else aware that she even took photographs, much less ones of this calibre, but apparently Maier herself was unaware of the quality of her work. But for their chance discovery, these works of art could have been lost forever.And what works they are - they bring to mind the eye for the offbeat and macabre seen in Diane Arbus' work, but with a crucial difference. While Arbus' best photographs have been compared to staring down the barrel of a gun, in order to achieve this power, one has the sense that she was not being entirely true to her subjects, that there is a certain betrayal - of using them for her own purposes rather than showing them for who they were. There is none of this dissimulation in Maier's work - the subjects are authentic, captured in the activities of their real lives.As street photography, Maier shares some of Cartier-Bresson's spontaneity and element of surprise, but with a playfulness and humor often not present in his work. Cartier-Bresson used a Leica rangefinder, which has the advantage of rapid focusing, while Maier used a Rollei twin-lens reflex. While the Rollei is slower (focus is with a groundglass), it allows the photographer to face the subject without the camera in front of their face. While many of Maier's photos are clearly candid shots, several must have required her to get to know the subject on some level, however briefly, to gain their confidence and permission. Possibly having children with her made this easier - instead of the dedicated (and necessarily self-focused) solitary street photographer, she may have come across as an unthreatening tourist, taking the photo as a minor diversion from her main activity - which is, in fact, what it was.Several other reviewers have taken the position that John Maloof is milking Maier's legacy for his own personal enrichment. One of Maier's distant relatives has filed a lawsuit seeking a share of Maloof's profits, the outcome of which is unknown at the time of this writing. My opinion is that Maier's work is a clear example of collaboration (one-sided though it is), and if Maloof had not taken the trouble and expense of developing, printing, and publicizing Maier's work, I have no doubt that it would be unknown to this day. I'm reminded of an episode of a television show where a man "discovered" the work of an obscure artist, managed to get the artist's work displayed in galleries, and made a great deal of money from this. The artist's descendants sued him, and during the trial it was revealed that they had used the artist's work they still owned as dropcloths or other mundane uses. The point was made that the only reason the artist was known at all was because of the man's efforts. I see the situation here as analagous - does anyone expect Maloof to do all this work for free, and for what? The enrichment of Maier's third cousin in France who probably never even spoke to her, and may not have even known that she existed? Or should he do this as a "gift to humanity" with no thought for himself? This attitude is unrealistic and in a sense ungrateful. How many other people handled Maier's photographs and thought nothing of them until Maloof stumbled across them?The book's preface asks what surprising, hidden talents the people Maier photographed may have possessed themselves - does Maier's own image possibly exist in the aeuvre of some other hitherto unknown street photographer? Diane Arbus said "there are things which nobody would see unless I photographed them," and Maier reminds us of how much of the world around us we are missing.

5.0 out of 5 stars EXCELENTE

C.H.R. · September 4, 2025

Me encanto libro de pasta dura, elgente pero lo mejor son las imagenes que estan dentro

Excelente libro

P.p. · September 11, 2025

Excelente libro

Beau livre

a. · June 14, 2025

Belles qualités d’image et d’impression

good quality

I. · August 29, 2019

Overall good quality, good photos, make me think a bit more and watch the street in a different way after reading this.

EXCELENTE

W.C.G. · June 28, 2021

A qualidade da impressão e acabamento do livro é inquestionável.Belas fotografias, trabalho e história incrível.Conhecer a história e o trabalho da Vivian Maier é algo obrigatório para qualquer um que se interesse por fotografia.

Excellent Quality

P. · October 19, 2021

I love the story. I love the images. I love the book.It is an excellent representation of Vivian's work. The book is excellent quality, nice quality paper and large images. I have nothing negative to say about physical quality or content.I am only puzzled by the blank pages. SERIOUSLY?? Blank pages in a coffee table photography book? What is that all about?? I am sure they will not do this again in future books.If you are a fan, buy the book. Vivian should be remembered. In my opinion, she is one of the greats. Her street photography is really something. To me, a good photograph makes your mind ask many questions. The more you wonder, the more the image is a certified gem. The book is pretty much filled with these types of images, cover to cover.Some of the images you have already seen online. SO? lol The detail in the book is much better. She used a large format camera and that really comes through with the printed image.For me, the book is a keeper. Buy it, cherish it.